Texas Supreme Court Overturns $116M Verdict in Deadly Highway Collision, Redefines Proximate Cause Standards
The Texas Supreme Court delivered a significant ruling Friday that overturned an $89 million jury verdict against Werner Enterprises and truck driver Shiraz Ali, establishing new precedent for determining liability in highway collision cases. The court ruled that despite evidence of the truck driver's negligence, he cannot be held responsible for injuries caused when an out-of-control pickup truck crossed a 42-foot median into oncoming traffic.
Read MoreRecent Articles
Are You an Expert Witness?
Increase your visibility and get more cases
Top Areas of Law
Personal Injury and Torts
View AllNegligence
View AllPersonal Injury
View AllPremises Liability
View All
Latest Verdicts & Settlements

Texas Supreme Court Overturns $116M Verdict in Deadly Highway Collision, Redefines Proximate Cause Standards
June 28, 2025
The Texas Supreme Court delivered a significant ruling Friday that overturned an $89 million jury verdict against Werner Enterprises and truck driver Shiraz Ali, establishing new precedent for determining liability in highway collision cases. The court ruled that despite evidence of the truck driver's negligence, he cannot be held responsible for injuries caused when an out-of-control pickup truck crossed a 42-foot median into oncoming traffic.

Florida Jury Awards $82K in Legal Fee Dispute Case
June 27, 2025
In a business dispute over unpaid legal fees, a Florida jury ruled in favor of PWBC, LLC, awarding $82,457.34 against The Manors Club, Inc. The case stemmed from a 2020 retainer agreement with law firm Katzman Chandler, which later assigned its claim to PWBC. The Manors Club never disputed invoices for legal services performed but failed to pay. At trial, PWBC presented itemized bills, email records, and the signed agreement, asserting claims for breach of contract, open account, account stated, and unjust enrichment. The defense argued the contract lacked board approval and challenged the fees’ validity. On April 16, 2025, the jury found the agreement enforceable, the services properly rendered, and the defendant liable for full payment.

A Los Angeles jury awarded $27.5 million to Nancy Valla, a former nurse executive at St. Mary Medical Center, operated by Dignity Health. Valla alleged she was retaliated against and constructively terminated after pushing for suicide-prevention measures following a tragic death on hospital grounds. She also sought accommodations for PTSD and depression, which she claimed were denied. The jury found that Dignity Health had discriminated against her and failed to accommodate her mental health disability. The swift and unanimous verdict delivered a clear rebuke of the hospital’s treatment of a whistleblower and healthcare professional seeking workplace support.

A Florida jury awarded SK Invest Group $735,610 after finding First Florida International (FFI) and owner Edward Genin liable for charging for work never performed, breaching contract, and committing fraud in a renovation project.

A Contra Costa County jury awarded Alpha GRP, Inc. $73,474 in its lawsuit against broker Woodruff-Sawyer & Co. for negligent advice on insurance coverage during a business shutdown. The jury found the broker partially liable for recommending tail policies that excluded creditor claims, but also held Alpha mostly responsible. Claims brought by Alpha’s officer Colin Dyne were denied.

Left Turn Crash: $402K Jury Verdict for Erik Ramos
June 26, 2025
A New Haven jury awarded Erik Ramos $402,340 after a left‑turn crash caused by Alan Barton. The verdict found Barton acted negligently and recklessly, making him liable for medical expenses, pain, and emotional distress. Al’s Plumbing and Heating LLC was cleared of any responsibility.

Francois and Marceline Julmis filed a declaratory relief action against Citizens Property Insurance Corporation after a February 2022 plumbing leak damaged their Miami home. The insurer denied their claim, citing maintenance issues and policy exclusions. The Julmises argue the loss falls under their all-risk policy and are asking the court to compel coverage and appraisal, citing damages exceeding $50,000.

Jury Awards $216K in Rear-End Crash Injury Lawsuit
June 26, 2025
Phoebe Griffith filed a personal injury lawsuit after being rear-ended by Emily Rosso on Route 15 in Norwalk. The December 2021 crash caused lasting spinal injuries and led to extensive medical treatment. Griffith brought her case before the Superior Court in Bridgeport, alleging negligence and unsafe driving. On January 16, 2025, a jury ruled in her favor, awarding $216,380 in total damages for medical expenses and pain and suffering.

A jury in Miami-Dade County returned a verdict in favor of the City of Miami and Officer Kennht Brito in a personal injury lawsuit brought by Florence Mueller. The case stemmed from a 2019 rear-end collision involving a city-owned vehicle. Mueller claimed permanent injuries and sought over $30,000 in damages. The defense argued no negligence occurred, and the jury agreed—awarding no compensation.

Jorge Jimenez sued Luis Diaz after a rear-end crash in Cheshire, Connecticut, claiming injuries and negligence. Jimenez sought over $15,000 for physical and emotional harm. Diaz denied liability and blamed Jimenez’s own driving. After hearing arguments from both sides, a Hartford jury ruled in favor of Diaz on January 16, 2025, finding no negligence and awarding zero damages.

A Stamford jury awarded Milagros Pereyra $638,265 after a crash caused by Carlos Palencia‑Carrera, who was driving under the influence. The verdict included economic and noneconomic damages for serious injuries and long‑term pain. The jury found Palencia‑Carrera acted recklessly, making him liable for punitive and double damages.

Dan Alexis sued Union Autobody Shop and others over a 2020 hit-and-run crash on I-95. Despite the defense denying liability, a jury awarded Alexis $1.95 million for injuries, pain, and suffering. The verdict held all defendants, including Union Autobody, responsible for the collision.
On the Stand with Ashish Arun
A podcast on the law, practice and business of expert witness testimony. Listen to the latest episodes.