Negligence

State Farm sued the City and County of San Francisco after a decayed tree collapsed onto a home, causing over $434,000 in damages. Despite repeated warnings, the City failed to act. The City denied responsibility, raising multiple defenses, including statutory immunity. The case ended in a confidential out-of-court settlement on September 19, 2024.

On June 29, 2024, a ceiling collapse in a Miami apartment injured Raquel Recio de Roman while she slept. She and her husband sued the building owner, Little Havana Equities LLC, for negligence and loss of consortium. After the defendant failed to respond, the plaintiffs obtained a default judgment. On June 11, 2025, the Court awarded them $175,000 in damages for medical expenses, emotional distress, and economic loss.

Julio Cesar Ceballo Fuentes filed a lawsuit against EMTS Parts & Services, Inc., alleging negligence and breach of contract after a fall from his truck. EMTS denied responsibility, claiming the plaintiff acted on his own and raised multiple affirmative defenses. On June 11, 2025, a jury found in favor of EMTS, concluding the company was not liable for any injuries or damages, and rejecting all claims brought by the plaintiff.

Angela Samuels sued Miami-Dade County after hitting a pothole on a public road in 2020, claiming serious injury and negligence. She alleged the County failed to maintain safe road conditions. On April 1, 2025, a jury found in favor of the County, concluding it was not liable for her injuries.

In January 2025, a Miami-Dade jury awarded $563,325 to Binish Mahmood in a negligent security lawsuit after her apartment was burglarized. The verdict held the building’s owner and parking operators responsible for failing to staff and monitor the property’s garage, which allowed masked intruders to access and ransack her unit. Mahmood lost over $300,000 in luxury goods and cash and brought claims of negligence and inadequate supervision against multiple parties, including the dissolved entity’s operator.

A Contra Costa County jury awarded Alpha GRP, Inc. $73,474 in its lawsuit against broker Woodruff-Sawyer & Co. for negligent advice on insurance coverage during a business shutdown. The jury found the broker partially liable for recommending tail policies that excluded creditor claims, but also held Alpha mostly responsible. Claims brought by Alpha’s officer Colin Dyne were denied.

A Stamford jury awarded Milagros Pereyra $638,265 after a crash caused by Carlos Palencia‑Carrera, who was driving under the influence. The verdict included economic and noneconomic damages for serious injuries and long‑term pain. The jury found Palencia‑Carrera acted recklessly, making him liable for punitive and double damages.

A New Haven jury awarded Erik Ramos $402,340 after a left‑turn crash caused by Alan Barton. The verdict found Barton acted negligently and recklessly, making him liable for medical expenses, pain, and emotional distress. Al’s Plumbing and Heating LLC was cleared of any responsibility.

A flooding dispute at a luxury Aventura condo led to a trial between Saveway C.V. and Haim Cohen Saban. The jury found no negligence and ruled in favor of Saban.

Judith Bellemare’s lawsuit over a 2019 Wolcott car crash ended with a defense win. A Waterbury jury found no negligence or recklessness by Michael Whitney and awarded no damages.

A Bridgeport jury found in favor of ERT Harborview, LLC and Harborview Market, LLC, rejecting claims brought by Randy Zingo over a falling ceiling fixture. Zingo alleged he suffered serious physical and emotional injuries when a light struck him inside the business in 2021. He sued both the property owner and the market operator for negligence, but the jury determined neither party was at fault and awarded no damages.

A New Haven jury returned a defense verdict in favor of Ed and Lisa Albarino, the landlords accused of negligence and recklessness after tenant Stephanie White claimed she fell down a stairway due to a detached railing in her Clinton, Connecticut rental. White sought damages for serious leg and ankle injuries, but the jury awarded her nothing, finding no liability.