Jurimatic: Verdicts and Settlements

This medical malpractice lawsuit arose from a series of clinical encounters beginning in October 2019. Alexander R. Sommers, a resident of North Haven, sought treatment for sudden visual impairments in his right eye, describing a shadow like an "eclipse" blocking his vision. The plaintiff alleged that healthcare providers at Yale New Haven Health and the Yale Eye Center failed to timely and accurately diagnose a retinal detachment, initially misidentifying the issue as a neurological condition. This delay allegedly led to permanent and disabling damage, including a severe MRSA infection following eventual surgery. The defense maintained that the medical team acted appropriately based on the clinical information available at the time. Following a trial in November 2025, the jury returned a verdict in favor of the defendants, finding no liability for the hospital or the individual physicians.

A Connecticut jury awarded Giya Perrin $10,057 after finding Alain Malimba fully responsible for a 2022 highway collision on Interstate 91 South in New Haven. The jury rejected the defense's contributory negligence argument and assigned 100% liability to the defendant for the early morning crash that left Perrin with spinal injuries.

On November 21, 2022, a significant motor vehicle collision occurred in Darien, Connecticut, when a vehicle operated by John Romanovsky and owned by Hood Services 24 LLC struck the rear of a vehicle driven by Extra Desther on Ledge Road. The impact resulted in Desther suffering from cervical and lumbar radiculopathy, persistent hand pain, and the aggravation of a pre-existing spinal condition. Represented by The Flood Law Firm, LLC, Desther argued that Romanovsky’s negligence—specifically failing to maintain a proper lookout and following too closely—was the direct cause of his permanent physical and mental suffering. While the defense admitted the collision occurred, they vigorously contested the extent of the injuries and the necessity of the claimed medical expenses. The trial concluded in the Superior Court of Fairfield at Bridgeport with a jury verdict totaling $488,958.89. This award included $35,563.89 in past medical expenses, $133,107.00 for future medical care, and $320,288.00 in noneconomic damages for pain and suffering. Notably, the jury meticulously reviewed medical provider bills, opting to award specific amounts to providers like Stamford Hospital and CARE Health & Wellness while declining others.

A Broward County jury ruled in favor of Barbara Corsale LLC in a breach of contract lawsuit against Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company. The dispute arose from a June 2022 water damage incident at a Deerfield Beach condominium. While the insurer argued that the damage resulted from long-term seepage or faulty maintenance—both of which were excluded under the policy—the jury rejected these defenses. The verdict confirmed that the loss was a direct, covered event and that the homeowner had fully complied with all post-loss obligations. The Court ordered the insurer to pay the actual cash value of the damages, reinforcing homeowner protections against wrongful claim denials based on unsubstantiated policy exclusions.

A Middlesex County jury delivered a defense verdict in favor of Sage Dining Services, Inc., ending a legal challenge brought by former Food Service Director Timothy Jones. Jones had alleged that the company terminated his employment in December 2022 as direct retaliation for his efforts to report sexual harassment involving a district manager. While the plaintiff argued that his firing occurred immediately after he escalated these concerns to Human Resources, the defense maintained that all employment decisions were made in good faith for legitimate business reasons. After reviewing the evidence, the jury found that Jones did not meet the burden of proof required for a retaliation claim under Connecticut law, resulting in a total victory for the employer.

A legal battle spanning several years concluded in the Ninth Judicial Circuit Court when a jury held the owners and operators of Flash Dancers Nightclub accountable for the 2019 shooting death of Stephen R. Walker. The estate successfully argued that the defendants failed to provide adequate security despite a known history of criminal activity in the area. The jury found that both the landlord, Krej Leasing, Inc., and the operator, OC Flashdancers, LLC, exhibited wanton negligence. Specifically, the court determined that the defendants failed to warn the victim of dangerous conditions on the premises. The final verdict apportioned 80% of the fault to the nightclub operator and 20% to the leasing company, awarding $305,000.60 to cover funeral expenses and the mental pain and suffering of Walker's surviving children.

On November 25, 2018, 19-year-old Nora Rose-Hines attempted a left turn from Strathern Street onto Balboa Boulevard in Los Angeles. As she entered the intersection, a vehicle driven by Tiana Brown struck her car on the driver’s side. The impact caused fatal injuries to Nora. Her mothers, Patricia Hines and Margot Rose, filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the City of Los Angeles and CalTrans. They alleged the intersection was a dangerous condition of public property because it lacked the safety modifications necessary to handle high traffic volumes and had a history of similar accidents. While the City initially argued that Nora was negligent and the intersection met design standards, the parties eventually reached a settlement of $1,850,000 to resolve the litigation.

A Los Angeles County jury delivered a significant verdict in favor of Art City Center LLC, holding global retailer Gap, Inc. accountable for breaching a commercial lease agreement. The dispute arose after Gap transformed a 57,000-square-foot warehouse at 1360 East 6th Street into a specialized set, allegedly gutting the interior and installing unauthorized structural changes. Art City Center argued that because Gap failed to restore the building to "good operating order" by the May 31, 2022 deadline, the retailer had not legally surrendered the property. The jury agreed, finding that Gap’s failure to return the premises in the required condition constituted a "holdover" of the lease. Consequently, the jury awarded Art City Center $1,294,875.77 in holdover damages and an additional award for repair costs, totaling more than $1.3 million in damages against the clothing giant.

Following a 2017 plumbing failure in Coral Springs, Frank and Barbara Savalli entered an eight-year legal battle with People’s Trust Insurance Company. The conflict centered on the insurer’s "Option to Repair" clause, which the homeowners alleged was used as a tactic to "low-ball" restoration costs. In December 2025, a Broward County jury reached a unanimous verdict, finding that People’s Trust acted in bad faith, made purposeful misrepresentations, and failed to uphold its duty to restore the property to its pre-loss condition.

On November 26, 2022, Ryen Motzek was traveling eastbound in a designated bike lane on Eddy Street in San Francisco when he was struck by a 2021 Honda Accord. The vehicle, owned by Dwight Hall and operated by Kendu Bomani, caused Motzek to suffer severe bodily injuries requiring immediate and long-term medical intervention. Motzek filed suit (Case No. CGC24611404) alleging both the driver's negligence and the owner’s negligent entrustment of the vehicle. Although the defense initially contested the allegations—citing contributory negligence and the statute of limitations—the parties ultimately reached a $420,000 settlement. This award compensates the plaintiff for past and future medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering resulting from the collision.

A West Covina homeowner’s decision to skip building permits led to a $550,000 legal settlement after a guest suffered a life-altering fall. In October 2019, Dennis Brown visited the home of Victoria and Frank Fusaro at 1440 South Meeker Avenue. He stepped out onto a newly renovated patio, unaware that the recent construction work created a dangerous nine-inch vertical drop. The height discrepancy violated local building codes and lacked any visual warnings or handrails. This hazard caused Brown to lose his balance and strike the hard stone pavers with immense force. The resulting injuries inflicted immediate trauma and left Brown with permanent physical limitations. After Brown filed a premises liability claim in Los Angeles Superior Court, the parties reached a financial agreement to address his mounting medical bills and lost earning capacity.

Amelia Sellers and Christian Chico expected a routine evening when they visited the Greek Theatre in November 2021. They had just entered the area known as Lot H when a massive 90-foot Aleppo Pine tree suddenly uprooted and crashed onto them. The impact pinned both pedestrians to the ground and inflicted life-altering injuries that required immediate hospital intervention. Before the accident happened, the tree had reportedly shown signs of instability and root decay. The plaintiffs filed a lawsuit against the City of Los Angeles, the County of Los Angeles, and ASM Global Theater Management. They alleged that the defendants failed to maintain the grounds and ignored a dangerous condition on public property. The defense initially argued that the collapse was an unforeseeable accident, but experts for the plaintiffs pointed to visible markers of neglect. Shortly before the trial began, the defendants agreed to a $1,150,000 settlement to resolve the claims and provide for the victims' future medical needs.