Case Background

On August 13, 2020, Jenny Ramirez Valdivia rode her scooter along The Embarcadero near Pier 19 in San Francisco. The sidewalk was dimly lit, and a concrete barrier stood in the middle of the pathway. City and county officials owned, managed, and controlled the sidewalk. Valdivia’s ride turned dangerous when the poorly maintained and illuminated walkway created a hidden hazard. The evening journey quickly set the stage for a serious accident.

Cause

Valdivia lost control of her scooter when she struck the barrier. She fell violently to the ground. The complaint alleged the City and County of San Francisco failed to maintain the sidewalk. Officials allegedly ignored the poor lighting and dangerous placement of the barrier. Valdivia claimed the government entities created or allowed a hazardous condition. She argued they knew, or should have known, such a condition could injure pedestrians and riders.

Injury

The fall left Valdivia seriously hurt. She sustained significant physical injuries and endured pain and suffering. She req