Jury Clears Miami Couple in Fireworks Injury Lawsuit

Case Background

On July 4, 2020, a holiday celebration in a quiet Miami neighborhood turned into a legal battle that lasted over four years. The case centered on an injury suffered by Darlus L. West, who claimed he was struck in the eye by a firework launched from a party at the home of Javon and Taron Bethel. West argued that the Bethels either provided or allowed fireworks to be set off during their gathering, creating a dangerous condition that extended beyond their property line and into the public sidewalk.

West’s lawsuit alleged that the Bethels failed to maintain their property safely and failed to protect pedestrians from foreseeable harm. The case raised broader questions about responsibility during private celebrations, particularly when injuries occur off the homeowner’s property but are linked to activity originating there.

Cause

West filed a negligence action against both Javon and Taron Bethel. He asserted that they had breached their legal duty to maintain a safe environment and prevent dangerous conditions from affecting passersby. According to the complaint, the Bethels had hosted a party at their residence at 16631 S.W. 105th Avenue, Miami, and either provided or allowed guests to use fireworks.

West claimed that one of the fireworks flew off the Bethels’ property and struck him while he was walking on the public sidewalk, causing serious injury to his right eye.

Injury

The Plaintiff said the explosion caused lasting damage to his eye and face. His complaint described pain and suffering, disfigurement, loss of enjoyment of life, and emotional distress, along with medical expenses and lost earnings. He also claimed that his injuries aggravated a preexisting condition, further reducing his ability to work and enjoy normal activities.