Calvin Raymond v. ATN Nails and Spa, LLC et al.

Case Background

After a manicure led to a severe finger infection, Calvin Raymond filed a personal injury lawsuit against ATN Nails and Spa alleging negligence. The case was filed in the  St. Louis County Circuit Court, Missouri. Judge Brian May presided over this case. [Case number: 22SL-CC03303]

Cause

One Sunday, Christine Raymond, Plaintiff Calvin Raymond’s wife, persuaded him to join her for a mani-pedi at ATN Nails and Spa. During the manicure, a technician accidentally cut Raymond’s finger, leading to an infection. After three or four days, the injury showed no signs of improvement, prompting him to visit urgent care.

The medical staff prescribed antibiotics, but over the next two to three weeks, his condition worsened. He noticed drainage and other troubling symptoms beneath the nail. Eventually, the situation required the intervention of an orthopedic doctor.

The doctor performed surgery, removing the nail and cleaning out the nail bed. Additionally, they sent a sample of Raymond’s finger to the lab for analysis. The lab results indicated a resistant strain of bacteria, which could only be treated with intravenous antibiotics.

Damages

The aftermath of the trip led to an infection and an injury, costing Raymond months of lost wages. He had to take time off work to undergo IV treatments.

Key Arguments and Proceedings

Legal Representation

  • Plaintiff(s): Calvin Raymond
    • Counsel for Plaintiff(s): Scott D. Kehlenbrink
  • Defendant(s): ATN Nails and Spa, LLC
    • Counsel for Defendant(s): Dan Wilke

Claims

Calvin Raymond claimed negligence on the part of ATN Nails and Spa. He argued that the technician’s careless actions caused his injury and subsequent infection, leading to significant medical expenses and lost wages.

Defense

ATN Nails and Spa contended that they provided adequate training and supervision for their staff. They argued that the injury resulted from an unexpected accident and that they followed proper procedures in response to the incident.

Jury Verdict

On September 26, 2024, the Missouri jury returned a verdict in favor of Plaintiff. They assigned $100,000 in non-economic damages and $12,000 in economic damages. Thus, the total award was $112,000.

Court Documents:

Available upon request