Heath Wilson vs. Donald Beiler, et al
Case Background
On November 11, 2022, Wilson filed a bicycle accident lawsuit in the Court of Common Pleas of Chester County, Philadelphia. However, the case was transferred to Chester County in 2023 (Case Number: 2023-02714), as the defendant company, JM Lapp Plumbing, conducts business there. Although the crash occurred in Lancaster County, jurisdiction was shifted to accommodate the business location. Judge Sarah B. Black presided over the proceedings.
Cause
The incident occurred on July 16, 2022, on a heavily used bike and pedestrian trail that intersects Bushong Road in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. Wilson, a 51-year-old man, was riding westward on the popular Enola Low Grade Trail, a well-traveled path stretching from Atglen in Chester County to the Susquehanna River near Conestoga. While entering the intersection, which lacked stop or warning signs, Wilson was struck by a Ford Econoline 350 truck owned by JM Lapp Plumbing. The truck was driven by Beiler, a longtime resident of Bushong Road.
Beiler, traveling at 29 miles per hour, had a clear line of sight to Wilson but collided with him nonetheless. The impact ejected Wilson from his bicycle, throwing him onto the truck’s hood and launching him 25 feet away. The lawsuit claimed that Beiler ignored the three-tiered warning signs at the crossing, despite knowing the area’s high pedestrian and cyclist traffic. This bicycle accident highlighted serious safety concerns at the intersection.
Injuries
The collision caused Wilson catastrophic injuries, including a traumatic axonal brain injury that left him in a prolonged coma. He also suffered a closed head injury, blunt brain trauma, internal organ laceration, and intra-abdominal hemorrhage. Additional injuries included multiple rib and spinal fractures, a left lung contusion, blunt chest trauma, and the surgical removal of his spleen.
These injuries left Wilson with long-term physical and cognitive impairments, significantly affecting his quality of life. The aftermath of the bicycle accident required extensive medical interventions and resulted in permanent disabilities that hindered his daily living and overall well-being.
Damages
Wilson’s injuries led to substantial medical expenses, including emergency surgeries, prolonged hospitalization, and extensive rehabilitation for brain trauma. The bicycle accident also prevented him from working, causing significant financial strain. He endured immense physical and emotional pain, alongside permanent disabilities that limited his ability to enjoy life.
The lawsuit sought compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, ongoing care costs, and damages for physical and emotional suffering. The financial burdens resulting from this devastating bicycle accident underscored the need for accountability and justice.
Key Arguments and Proceedings
Legal representation
- Plaintiff(s): Heath Wilson
- Counsel for Plaintiff: Clancy Boylan | Hannah J. Molitoris
- Defendant(s):Donald Beiler | JM Lapp Plumbing and Heating LLC
- Counsel for Defendants: Cecil Jones | Eric Freed | Kevin F. Farrington
Key Arguments or Remarks by Counsel
“We are proud of the 12 Chester County citizens who delivered justice for Heath Wilson last Friday,” said attorney K. Clancy Boylan of the Philadelphia law firm of Morgan and Morgan, who represented Wilson, in an email Wednesday. “Their verdict will give Heath the means and access to obtain the care he needs to be able to come back from the severe traumatic brain injury he suffered.
“In closing arguments, I asked the jury to choose hard and be proud of their verdict,” he added. “Friday’s verdict gave hope to a man who has lived an absolute nightmare for the last two-and-a-half years.”
Claims
The lawsuit alleged that Beiler’s negligence directly caused Wilson’s injuries and damages. Wilson had the right of way on the Enola Low Grade Trail, which was free of stop or warning signs. In contrast, Beiler failed to heed the three-tiered warning signs on Bushong Road and did not exercise reasonable caution. Despite a clear line of sight, Beiler collided with Wilson, causing the bicycle accident and its tragic consequences.
The claim also emphasized that Beiler, a resident of the area for eight years, knew about the high traffic of cyclists and pedestrians at the crossing. By ignoring this awareness and the posted warnings, Beiler’s actions were deemed reckless.
Defense
The defense argued that Wilson, an experienced cyclist, failed to exercise proper caution while crossing Bushong Road. They claimed he entered the intersection without adequately assessing oncoming traffic. Despite his familiarity with cycling and traffic rules, Wilson did not slow down or yield, contributing to the bicycle accident.
Beiler, the defense maintained, was driving lawfully at 29 miles per hour and adhered to the warning signs on Bushong Road. They argued that Wilson’s sudden entry into the roadway left Beiler with limited time to react. The defense also pointed to the clear layout of the intersection, asserting that Wilson should have been more vigilant given his cycling experience.
Ultimately, the defense contended that Wilson’s failure to exercise due care caused the accident, disputing any negligence on Beiler’s part.
Jury Verdict
On December 6, 2024, the jury awarded Wilson a total of $29 million in damages, recognizing the extensive harm caused by the bicycle accident. This amount included approximately $10.9 million for medical expenses, $2.2 million for lost earnings, and $16 million for noneconomic damages, such as pain and suffering, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life. However, the jury determined that Wilson bore 15% comparative negligence for the accident. As a result, the court reduced his compensation proportionally, molding the verdict to reflect his share of responsibility. The final award was adjusted to $24.7 million in a bicycle accident lawsuit.
Court Documents:
Documents Available for Purchase upon Request
Press Release:
Leave A Comment